JSE Author Guidelines – Updated November 2026
Submit to journalofscientificexploration.org
General Submission Requirements
JSE publishes Regular Articles, Literature Reviews, Student and Citizen Science papers, Brief Reports, Book and Multimedia Reviews, Essays, and Letters. Invited content in these categories is also published periodically. Authors are responsible for ensuring their submissions meet APA Guidelines (7th edition) and conform to the parameters below.
There are no strict word limits, but guidelines for different types of submissions are given below. In all cases, authors should be as clear, direct, and concise as possible in their presentations. The Editor-in-Chief reserves the right to mandate revisions to the lengths of accepted papers in the interest of readability, accessibility, and space.
Contributions can be empirical research, critical or integrative reviews of the literature, position papers, policy perspectives, or comments and criticisms. Studies can adopt diverse methods, including qualitative, ethnographic, historical, survey, philosophical, case study, quantitative, experimental, quasi-experimental, data mining, and data analytics approaches.
Manuscript Types and Requirements
- Regular Articles (~11K words max). Primary research or interesting and important theoretical papers that foster the diversity and debate inherent to the scientific process. This entails novel or innovative ideas that have some ‘fragmentary' experimental or empirical support but which can be evaluated with logic and open-mindedness to present academia with provocative hypotheses that would otherwise be rejected by most conventional journals.
- All empirical results that have not been replicated should be called ‘preliminary’ with the findings treated as such. Peer-review and publication priority will be given to studies that are (a) pre-registered or (b) replications. Note that ‘replication’ can involve repeating the research procedure in a (nearly) identical separate study to be reported within the same paper (e.g., ‘Study 2: Replication’). Or, large datasets can be divided randomly into ‘Training’ and ‘Test (or Validation)’ sets, i.e., the research findings presented are those results that replicated in the Test set.
- To promote stricter transparency and context for readers, all analyses where appropriate should provide effect size statistics in the form of direct percentages of either association (correlative analysis) or mean percentage differences (ANOVA, t-tests, etc.). In the case of correlative analysis, reported results shall report R2 to provide a covariance percentage estimate. Mean tests shall provide a ‘percentage change’ indicating the actual percentage change between groups (e.g., M = 3.44 Group 1 versus M = 4.02, in Group 2, on a five-point scale is calculated by the following: ABS [M1 – M2/5 (scale range)] = 11.6% shift or change in means). Standard effect statistics also are allowed, so long as the above percentage techniques are likewise reported. These statistics should be reported in results as ‘percentage effect’ and follow immediately after standard statistical analysis notation. For correlation, (r = .43, p < .01, percentage effect = 18%), for means tests (M1 = 3.44 versus M2 = 4.02, t = 3.443, p < .01, percentage effect = 11.6%).
- Systematic, Narrative, and Scoping Reviews (~12K words max). All meta-analyses and systematic reviews should include a PRISMA flow diagram to clarify for readers how the exclusion/inclusion criteria were applied to create the literature set under consideration: See http://www.prisma-statement.org/
- Brief Reports—Rapid Publications (~2K words max). These are usually pilot studies, direct or conceptual replication attempts of previous work, case studies, brief evaluations, reviews, or ‘citizen scientist’ efforts that are unique, first-time reports, with no more than two tables and/or figures and 10 references. This rapid publication option is especially appropriate for graduate-level student studies, pilot or preliminary research, or descriptions of important new methods or instrumentation. These reports are subject to blinded peer review in the same manner as research articles. Authors should follow all requirements for longer manuscripts when submitting Brief Reports, including that they have not been submitted or published elsewhere.
- Book and Multimedia Reviews (~2K words max). Structured for readability and utility in which the content is suitably contextualized and includes links to general model-building or theory-formation in the respective domain(s). Please use the following headers, or otherwise incorporate these themes into the review: (a) Author Disclosures; (b) Content Overview; (c) Pros, Cons, and the Book’s Contributions to the Literature; (d) Recommendation; and (e) References (if applicable). For an example, see: https://www.spr.ac.uk/book-review/poltergeist-night-side-physics-keith-linder
Multimedia reviews can cover films, documentaries, recorded presentations or symposia, video series and reports, websites that are comprehensive resources, software for scholars, and even peer-reviewed articles in other journals that are pertinent to frontier science. Submissions are now being accepted, and authors should note that these multimedia reviews should include four components: (a) Introduction; (b) Summary of the Media Content; (c) Description of the Value of the Media to the Journal’s Readership; and (d) Critique of the Media. These components need not constitute major sections, but each issue should be clearly addressed in the submission. We strongly encourage prospective authors to discuss their topic for a multimedia review with the subsection Editor Mel Larrosa (mel.larrosa@yahoo.com) prior to submission.
- Essays (~8K words max). Important conceptual or philosophical commentaries, observations, or arguments to spark constructive discussion or debate relative to theory, methodology, or practice.
- Letters (~1K words max). Must address substantive issues relative to recently published content in the Journal.
Additional Manuscript Requirements
Submissions (A) to (C), and (E) as appropriate, must also include the following information:
- Author affiliations. Please provide ORCID numbers for authors as available.
- Abstract (~150 words). JSE uses an unstructured format for summaries and encourages language accessible to readers across different disciplines.
- Implications and Applications (~150 words max). Placed immediately after the Discussion section to succinctly summarize or suggest how the study’s methods or findings can potentially inform the study of other issues, anomalies, or fields of study, including interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary approaches.
- Data-sharing requirements. Primary (raw) data (redacted for confidential or personally identifying information) must either be (a) uploaded to a freely accessible repository for independent verification or analysis by qualified researchers and the URLs shared in the paper and in a section called Data Availability under the Acknowledgments section (the Journal can provide such space), or (b) otherwise provided to qualified researchers on formal request.
- AI Use Disclosure. See ‘Journal of Scientific Exploration Policy on Artificial Intelligence Use’ below.
Table and Figure Preparation Guidelines
Tables and figures can help present complex information clearly. They should add value to the article and should not repeat information already presented in the text.
Please follow the requirements below when preparing and submitting tables and figures. Files that do not meet these requirements may be returned to the authors for revision.
Tables
- Create tables using the table function in Microsoft Word or another word-processing program. Do not use spaces or tabs to align columns.
- Do not submit tables as images or spreadsheet files.
- Tables, including their titles and notes, must fit within the Journal’s maximum typeset area of 75 inches wide by 8.5 inches high.
- Simplify or divide tables that exceed these dimensions. The Journal does not publish supplementary material.
- Number tables consecutively using Arabic numerals (Table 1, Table 2, Table 3, and so on) in the order in which they are first cited.
- Give each table a concise, descriptive title of no more than 15 words.
- Provide clear headings for all rows and columns and identify applicable units of measurement.
- Define abbreviations and provide any necessary explanatory notes below the table.
- Identify specific table notes using superscript lowercase letters (a, b, c, and so on).
- Use asterisks for probability notes, where applicable.
- Ensure that each table can be understood without reference to the article text.
Place all tables after the reference list, with each table on a separate page. Arrange them in consecutive order and cite every table in the article text. During article layout, tables will be placed close to their first citations.
Figures
Size and Resolution
Figures may be submitted in colour or black and white. When colour is used, the figure should not rely on colour alone to communicate important information. Use labels, symbols, or patterns where needed.
Figures must not exceed 6.75 inches wide by 8.5 inches high. This maximum includes all labels, legends, keys, and other elements within the figure. It does not include the figure title or explanatory note, which will be typeset separately.
The following minimum resolutions apply at the figure’s intended publication size:
- Illustrations and photographs: 300 dpi
- Line drawings containing grey or coloured elements: 600 dpi
- Black-and-white line drawings: 600–1,200 dpi
Text, symbols, and labels must remain clear when the figure is reduced to its intended publication size. Do not stretch or distort images.
File Formats and Submission
- Submit photographs in TIFF or high-quality JPEG format.
- Submit graphs and diagrams in PDF, EPS, or SVG format whenever possible.
- Avoid creating figures in Microsoft Word or PowerPoint, as their appearance may vary between computers.
- Save each figure as a separate file without its figure number, title, or explanatory note.
- Use simple file names, such as Figure 1.tif or Figure 2A.jpg.
- Upload each figure as an individual file during the online submission process. Do not embed figures in the manuscript.
Figure Titles, Legends, and Notes
- Number figures consecutively using Arabic numerals (Figure 1, Figure 2, Figure 3, and so on) in the order in which they are first cited.
- Give each figure a concise, descriptive title.
- Label the individual panels of a multi-panel figure using uppercase letters (A, B, C, and so on).
- Include any legend or key needed to explain symbols, colours, patterns, or other visual elements within the figure.
- Define abbreviations and provide any necessary explanatory information in a figure note.
- Ensure that each figure can be understood without reference to the article text.
Group all figure numbers, titles, and notes at the end of the manuscript, after the tables. Cite every figure in the article text. During article layout, figures will be placed close to their first citations.
Previously Published Material
Authors are responsible for obtaining permission to reproduce or adapt tables and figures that have previously been published. Acknowledgement of the original source and rights holder must be provided, and the original publication must be included in the reference list. Copies of any required permissions must be submitted to the Journal.
Journal of Scientific Exploration Policy on Artificial Intelligence Use
JSE permits responsible use of artificial intelligence (AI), including generative AI and large language models, as an assistive technology. The relevant question is how AI was used and whether the manuscript or review remains clearly the product of independent human authorship or expert judgement. AI cannot be an author, reviewer, editor, or decision-maker.
JSE evaluates unconventional subjects by the quality of their evidence, methods, reasoning, and reporting. Declared AI use neither favours nor prejudices a submission. This policy applies to manuscripts, peer review, editorial assessment, and production.
1. General requirements
- Human authors, reviewers, and editors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, reasoning, and recommendations produced in their names.
- AI output is not a scholarly source. Authors and reviewers must check claims, quotations, references, translations, code, data, and interpretations against appropriate original or independently verifiable sources.
- Confidential manuscripts, reviews, personal data, unpublished data, and protected material must not be entered into public, unsecured, or unauthorised AI systems.
- AI must not be used to fabricate, manipulate, conceal, or misrepresent evidence, results, references, authorship, or editorial judgement.
- The journal will assess AI use proportionately. A responsible declaration is not, by itself, evidence of poor Quality or misconduct.
2. Authors
2.1 Permitted uses
- Language editing, copyediting and proofreading, translation, accessibility, and formatting.
- Organisation of author-written notes, outlines, or summaries.
- Literature discovery or summarisation, provided that authors consult and cite the original sources.
- Assistance with code, data cleaning, exploratory analysis, or visualisation when the inputs, methods, and outputs remain verifiable and are checked by the authors.
- Preparation of diagrams or other visual material from author-generated data or verifiable source material, subject to disclosure and rights requirements.
2.2 Disclosure requirements
Authors must disclose any generative or other material AI use that affects research design, analysis, code, literature synthesis, interpretation, manuscript structure and drafting, translation, references, or visual content. Routine spelling correction or non-generative autocomplete normally need not be disclosed unless confidential material was processed.
The disclosure must state, as applicable, the tool and version, date or period of use, purpose, affected section or task, relevant inputs, and the checks performed. Research use belongs in the Methods or equivalent section. Manuscript-preparation use belongs in an AI Use Declaration or Acknowledgements section. AI-assisted visual content must also be identified in its caption or legend.
2.3 Prohibited uses
- Listing an AI system as an author or assigning it responsibility for the work.
- Generating or fabricating data, results, participant accounts, quotations, references, or conclusions.
- Presenting AI-generated reasoning or interpretation as independent human scholarship without appropriate disclosure and verification.
- Using AI to conceal plagiarism, unattributed copying, or a material lack of author contribution.
- Submitting AI-generated images or other visual material as documentary or empirical evidence when its origin and accuracy cannot be verified.
- Uploading confidential or protected material to a tool whose security, retention, training, or data-use terms have not been verified.
2.4 Author responsibility
- Authors must review and verify all AI-assisted material before submission.
- Authors should retain records of material AI use sufficient to explain the process and respond to editorial questions.
- Authors must correct any inaccurate, misleading, or undisclosed AI-assisted content identified during review or after publication.
- When using AI for data analysis, the authors must provide a clear rationale for its use including information on the reliability and reproducibility of the methods used. Each step in the analysis process should be clearly defined so that other authors are able to replicate them.
3. Peer reviewers
3.1 Permitted uses
- Organising the reviewer’s own notes or creating a checklist.
- Improving the clarity, grammar, or structure of comments already written by the reviewer.
- Exploring general methodological questions using the reviewer’s own notes or abstracted, non-identifying descriptions.
- Using a secure or institutionally approved tool where confidentiality and data-use protections are clear.
3.2 Prohibited uses
- Uploading a manuscript, figures, supplementary files, identifiable passages, novel results, or confidential correspondence to a public or unsecured AI tool.
- Using AI to generate all or a substantial part of a review report, critique, score, recommendation, or editorial decision.
- Using AI as a substitute for reading the manuscript or applying relevant expert knowledge.
- Using AI output as the sole basis for allegations of plagiarism, fabricated data, undisclosed AI use, or other misconduct.
- Sharing a manuscript or review report with an AI system in a way that compromises confidentiality, copyright, privacy, or data protection.
3.3 Reviewer disclosure
Reviewers must inform the editor of material AI use in preparing a report, including the tool, purpose, and whether it influenced the framing or substance of the assessment. The review must remain the reviewer’s own independent judgement. Reviewers who cannot protect confidentiality should not use AI for the assignment and should contact the editor if this affects their ability to review.
4. Associate editors and production
- Associate editors may use secure tools for limited administrative, language, formatting, or organisational assistance, but decisions on suitability, reviewer selection, conflicts of interest, integrity, and publication remain human decisions.
- AI may assist in identifying possible reviewers or organising workflow, but editors must independently verify expertise, independence, availability, and conflicts of interest.
- Editors must not upload unpublished manuscripts, reviews, personal data, or sensitive correspondence to public or unsecured tools.
- AI-detection scores are not proof of AI use, plagiarism, or misconduct. JSE will not reject or sanction a submission solely on the basis of an automated detection result or unusual writing style.
- AI-assisted copyediting, translation, metadata, or production must be checked by a responsible human for accuracy, omissions, altered meaning, and attribution.
5. Suggested declarations
Authors may adapt the following wording:
- Manuscript preparation: “During preparation of this manuscript, [tool and version] was used for [purpose] in [section or task]. The authors reviewed and verified the output and remain fully responsible for the content, accuracy, and interpretation of the manuscript.”
TRACE: Transparency in Reporting Anomalous Case Evidence
What TRACE is
TRACE is a nine-item disclosure standard for reports of spontaneous haunt-poltergeist cases, including field investigations, naturalistic or ecologically valid hypothesis testing, survey research, qualitative interview studies, archival case analyses, and other studies of lived experience. Its purpose is to make transparent how the evidence in a report was produced, recorded, and assessed.
It does not classify spontaneous cases, and it does not rate them as sound or compromised. It replaces the brief adjectival verdict — a case (or survey data, etc. derived from a spontaneous case) described as “pure,” “clean,” “unequivocal,” or “veridical” — with a disclosure profile that readers can weigh for themselves. Those single-word labels collapse three separate matters into one: (a) what kind of investigation was conducted, (b) how typical the reported events were, and (c) how tightly the evidence was controlled. TRACE separates them.
The precedents are STROBE in epidemiology, PRISMA for systematic reviews, CARE for clinical case reports, and APA’s JARS. None of those adjudicates findings. All of them make findings auditable.
The most important thing to understand
A “no” is a complete answer.
TRACE audits transparency, not evidentiary strength. A report that plainly discloses six unmet conditions satisfies this standard as fully as one that discloses six met conditions. A gap in your case’s evidentiary control is not a reason for rejection at the Journal of Scientific Exploration; it becomes part of the published record, so that readers can judge the report’s standing rather than relying on your assurance or ours. Accordingly, “TRACE-compliant” should never be used as shorthand for “methodologically strong” or “evidentially compelling”; it means only that the required disclosures have been made.
What is not acceptable is “silence.” An undisclosed item will be treated by reviewers as a flagged gap requiring an answer, not as a presumed absence of control.
None of the nine items asks you to have done anything additional in the field or with data collected from spontaneous case contexts. Each asks you only to report something you were already positioned to know.
Scope and effective date
TRACE applies to submissions reporting primary or secondary analysis of one or more spontaneous haunt–poltergeist (RSPK) cases, whether the material originated in field investigation, clinical engagement, or survey. For survey-derived material, TRACE applies when the manuscript presents or analyses identifiable case-level narratives or evidence; it does not apply to aggregated survey findings that do not constitute case reports.
It does not apply to laboratory experiments, theoretical papers, literature reviews, or commentary.
Effective for new submissions received on or after January 2027.
How to comply
Include a section headed TRACE Evidentiary Disclosure, placed as its own subsection, or part of an “Openness and Transparency” subsection, in the Method or your “References.” Address all nine items in order, as a numbered list or in continuous prose. Where an item does not apply to your report, say so and briefly explain why.
The nine items
1. Investigation Type
State whether the report is a field investigation undertaken, at least in part, to evaluate the veridicality of reported phenomena, or a clinical/therapeutic engagement in which anomalous-experience reports were incidental to a treatment relationship. State whether your aims were exploratory (documenting patterns, generating hypotheses, characterizing a case) or confirmatory (testing specific claims, ruling out alternatives, evaluating evidential strength). State whether the work is primarily descriptive/qualitative or psychometric/statistical/quantitative — particularly where psychological or environmental covariates are assessed.
2. Observer Independence
State which reported events, if any, were witnessed in real time by someone independent of the family or percipient group, as distinct from events reconstructed from retrospective account. Where independent observation occurred, give its duration and its proximity to the reported phenomena. Where it did not occur, say so plainly rather than leaving it to be inferred.
3. Data-Collector / Interpreter Separation
State whether anyone compiling the event record held a dual role — treating clinician, family member, or otherwise — relative to those constructing the case's clinical, psychodynamic, or parapsychological interpretation. Where separation was not maintained, state what steps, if any, were taken to limit the resulting risk of circularity.
4. Sequence of Investigator Contact
State what reassurance, normalization, or interpretive framing was communicated to percipients, and when, relative to the point at which the bulk of the case record was compiled. Where the record was compiled substantially after such framing was delivered, state whether the sequence introduced a potential risk of demand characteristics, expectancy effects, or retrospective reconstruction, and describe what steps, if any, were taken to address that risk.
5. Coding Reliability
For any thematic, symbolic, or pattern-based coding applied to case material, state whether that coding was blinded, independently rated, or governed by a pre-registered scheme. Where none of these applies, label the coding exploratory rather than confirmatory.
6. Hoax-Exclusion Basis
State whether fraud was ruled out on physical, forensic, or chain-of-custody grounds; on character assessment; or on some combination. Character assessment — that a family sought help rather than publicity or remained cooperative with treatment — may constitute contextual information relevant to the evaluation of fraud, but should be distinguished explicitly from physical, forensic, or chain-of-custody evidence.
7. Comparator Status
State whether any baseline period or comparator setting was used, considered, or feasible given the circumstances of the investigation. Where none was used, record this in the body of the report as a limitation.
8. Etiological Commitment
State explicitly the level of etiological inference the investigating team believes the evidence supports. This may include a conventional explanation, an anomalistic or parapsychological interpretation, consideration of multiple candidate explanations, or an explicitly agnostic position. Uncertainty is legitimate and common in this literature; disclose the team’s position at the outset rather than leaving it to be discovered after the case has been cited elsewhere as supporting or undermining a model.
9. Primary-Record Availability
State whether the complete primary record of reported events has been made available for external examination, in what form (original or derived), and by what route. State whether other collected material — instrument responses, recordings, session materials — is available or restricted, giving reasons for any restriction.
The fictitious example below shows how the disclosures should look in practice:
| TRACE Evidentiary Disclosure (Houran et al., 2027)
Reported in accordance with the TRACE standard, Items 1–9 in order.
|
|
|---|---|
| 1. Investigation Type | Field investigation, undertaken in part to evaluate the veridicality of the reported phenomena. Aims were exploratory for the phenomenological description and confirmatory for two pre-specified claims (repeated displacement of objects from a shelf; unattended movement of a latched door). The report is mixed-method, pairing a descriptive event narrative with standardized psychometric assessment of both adult occupants. |
| 2. Observer Independence | Of 47 logged events, 12 were witnessed in real time by an investigator with no prior relationship to the household; the remaining 35 were reconstructed from occupant report, in all cases within 24 hours. Independent observation totalled 96 hours across 14 overnight visits, with an investigator present in the room of report for 7 of the 12 witnessed events. |
| 3. Data-Collector / Interpreter Separation | Achieved in part. The event log was maintained by two investigators who took no part in the interpretive analysis, which was conducted by a third author who never met the occupants and worked from the log alone. Psychometric instruments were administered and scored by a colleague blind to the log. No independent audit of the log itself was performed. |
| 4. Sequence of Investigator Contact | No interpretive or normalizing framing was offered to the occupants before the event log closed, and investigators declined to answer questions about causation during fieldwork. A normalization and support discussion followed the final visit, after the log had closed; three events reported subsequently are excluded and described separately. |
| 5. Coding Reliability | Not met. No blinded, independently rated, or pre-registered coding was applied to the case material. The thematic groupings reported in the Results are the investigators’ own unblinded reading of the accounts, generated after fieldwork concluded. They are labelled exploratory and are not offered as independent corroboration of any model. |
| 6. Hoax-Exclusion Basis | Mixed. Sealed-thread markers at four recurrent object locations, continuous video in two rooms, and load-tested door hardware exclude occupant action for 9 of the 12 witnessed events. For the remaining 3, and for all 35 reconstructed events, exclusion rests on character assessment and opportunity reasoning, which we do not treat as evidentiarily equivalent. |
| 7. Comparator Status | Not met. No baseline period or comparator setting was used. Contact came five months after reported onset, so a pre-onset baseline was unavailable, and an instrumented quiet-period recording was proposed to the occupants and declined. This is a limitation of the report rather than an omission for a later reader to identify. |
| 8. Etiological Commitment | The investigators adopt an explicitly agnostic position regarding the case’s ultimate nature. We report that 5 events resist conventional explanation given the controls applied but treat this as supporting only a limited etiological inference: the events remain unexplained under the controls used. This is not equivalent to positive evidence for an anomalous mechanism. Where the Discussion entertains candidate accounts, they are identified as candidates rather than conclusions. |
| 9. Primary-Record Availability | The complete event log, field notes, coding records, and de-identified instrument responses are deposited at [repository/DOI]. Video is held by the corresponding author and available to qualified researchers under a data-use agreement, restricted because a minor is identifiable on it. No other material was withheld. |
Note. This case is a composite constructed for illustration and does not correspond to any published report; numerical values are illustrative. The specimen describes a comparatively well-controlled investigation, and two of the nine items are nonetheless disclosed as not met. It satisfies the standard in full, because every item is addressed and the grounds for each shortfall are stated. Authors may reproduce the layout; the wording is illustrative rather than model text.
On restricted records
Restriction is legitimate; concealment is not.
Clinical material gathered under therapeutic consent, data identifying private individuals, and material subject to legal constraint may all be properly withheld. Item 9 does not require you to open such records. It requires you to state that they exist, what they are, and on what ground access is limited. A record that is restricted for a stated reason is disclosed. A record whose existence is unmentioned is not.
How disclosures should be used downstream
TRACE governs the evidentiary record, not the analyses performed on it, and not the conclusions drawn from either. Two consequences follow for authors citing case reports in this literature:
- A report that is substantially clinical, exploratory, or descriptive should not be cited as evidence for or against a parapsychological model without the citation acknowledging that mismatch.
- Unblinded, singly-rated, or non-pre-registered coding should not be presented as independent corroboration of a theoretical model.
These are norms of inference, not conditions of acceptance. They are stated here because the disclosures exist to make them checkable.
Reuse and citation
This guidance is released under CC BY 4.0. Other journals and societies are free to adopt it The formal academic citation for TRACE is:
Houran, J., Maraldi, E. O., & Cooper, C. (2027). TRACE: A reporting standard for evidentiary control in haunt-poltergeist research. Journal of the Society for Psychical Research. Manuscript in press.
Section Policies
Research Articles
Primary research or interesting and important theoretical papers that foster the diversity and debate inherent to the scientific process. This entails novel or innovative ideas that have some ‘fragmentary’ experimental or empirical support but which can be evaluated with logic and open-mindedness to present academia with provocative hypotheses that would otherwise be rejected by most conventional journals.
- All empirical results that have not been replicated should be called ‘preliminary’ with the findings treated as such. Peer-review and publication priority will be given to studies that are (a) pre-registered or (b) replications. Note that ‘replication’ can involve repeating the research procedure in a (nearly) identical separate study to be reported within the same paper (e.g., ‘Study 2: Replication’). Or, large datasets can be divided randomly into ‘Training’ and ‘Test (or Validation)’ sets, i.e., the research findings presented are those results that replicated in the Test set.
- To promote stricter transparency and context for readers, all analyses where appropriate should provide effect size statistics in the form of direct percentages of either association (correlative analysis) or mean percentage differences (ANOVA, t-tests, etc.). In the case of correlative analysis, reported results shall report R2 to provide a covariance percentage estimate. Mean tests shall provide a ‘percentage change’ indicating the actual percentage change between groups (e.g., M = 3.44 Group 1 versus M = 4.02, in Group 2, on a five-point scale is calculated by the following: ABS [M1 – M2/5 (scale range)] = 11.6% shift or change in means). Standard effect statistics also are allowed, so long as the above percentage techniques are likewise reported. These statistics should be reported in results as ‘percentage effect’ and follow immediately after standard statistical analysis notation. For correlation, (r = .43, p < .01, percentage effect = 18%), for means tests (M1 = 3.44 versus M2 = 4.02, t = 3.443, p < .01, percentage effect = 11.6%).
Make a new submission to the Research Articles section.
Brief Report
These are usually pilot studies, direct or conceptual replication attempts of previous work, case studies, brief evaluations, reviews, or ‘citizen scientist’ efforts that are unique, first-time reports, with no more than two tables and/or figures and 10 references. This rapid publication option is especially appropriate for graduate-level student studies, pilot or preliminary research, or descriptions of important new methods or instrumentation. These reports are subject to blinded peer review in the same manner as research articles. Authors should follow all requirements for longer manuscripts when submitting Brief Reports, including that they have not been submitted or published elsewhere.
Make a new submission to the Brief Report section.
Review
Systematic, Narrative, and Scoping Reviews (~13K words max). All meta-analyses and systematic reviews should include a PRISMA flow diagram to clarify for readers how the exclusion/inclusion criteria were applied to create the literature set under consideration: See http://www.prisma-statement.org/
Make a new submission to the Review section.
Essay
Important conceptual or philosophical commentaries, observations, or arguments to spark constructive discussion or debate relative to theory, methodology, or practice.
Make a new submission to the Essay section.
Commentary
Important conceptual or philosophical commentaries, observations, or arguments to spark constructive discussion or debate relative to theory, methodology, or practice.
Make a new submission to the Commentary section.
Letter to the Editor
Must address substantive issues relative to recently published content in the Journal.
Make a new submission to the Letter to the Editor section.
Book and Multimedia Reviews
Reviews of Books, Articles, Videos, Websites, etc. Structured for readability and utility in which the content is suitably contextualized and includes links to general model-building or theory-formation in the respective domain(s). Please use the following headers, or otherwise incorporate these themes into the review: ‘Author Disclosures; Content Overview; Pros, Cons, and the Book’s Contributions to the Literature; Recommendation; and References’ (if applicable). For an example, see: https://www.spr.ac.uk/book-review/poltergeist-night-side-physics-keith-linder
Make a new submission to the Book and Multimedia Reviews section.
Abstracts
Article Abstract Only
Make a new submission to the Abstracts section.
Copyright Notice
Authors retain copyright to JSE articles and share the copyright with the JSE after publication.
Privacy Statement
The names and email addresses entered in this journal site will be used exclusively for the stated purposes of this journal and will not be made available for any other purpose or to any other party.
